Principle / circuitAdvanced

Discrimination (selectivity)

Arranging protection so only the device nearest a fault trips — not the whole board above it.

The idea

When a fault or overload happens, you want the protective device closest to it to operate, and everything upstream to stay in. That way a fault on one final circuit takes out only that circuit — not the sub-board, and certainly not the main switch feeding the whole installation.

Achieving that is discrimination (also called selectivity): choosing and grading the protective devices so their operating characteristics don't overlap in a way that lets an upstream device beat a downstream one to the trip.

How it's graded

Devices are graded on two axes: current (an upstream device is rated higher than the ones below it) and time (an upstream device is a little slower for a given fault level). For low-level overloads, the ratio of ratings usually gives discrimination. For high fault currents the fast magnetic trips can overlap, so time-grading or devices designed to coordinate are used.

The classic symptom of poor discrimination is an upstream breaker tripping for a fault that should have been cleared below it — a sub-main trips when a single circuit faults, or the main goes out for a downstream short. It's annoying domestically and serious on a site where one fault drops far more than it should.

Related faults

Related definitions